Raw Cheddar Cheese

The blessing of having a family milk cow is that you have plenty milk on hand.  Sometimes you feel you have too much milk, in fact.  What do we do with the extra milk?  We make Yogurt and Cheese.  Today I will share with you a step by step process of how I make cheddar Cheese…

First, measure and pour your milk into a stainless stock pot.  In this particular batch, I used 3 gallons of milk.  Normally, I make about 6-8 gallons at a time but that is just crazy to try to teach how to handle that amount at one time.  I poured 3 gallons of milk into the stock pot.  DO NOT SKIM THE CREAM!

Heat the milk slowly to 88˚ F.
Once the milk is 88˚ F, add just a pinch of MA culture, you can buy this here…http://www.getculture.com/MA-11.html
Stir in thoroughly.  I use a ladle and do the up and downward motion so that it evenly distribute the cream.
Leave this set, covered for 1 hour.

Add 1/4 teaspoon of liquid rennet per gallon and mix that into 1/4 cup of cool water.  Get your rennet here…http://www.getculture.com/DCI-Veal-rennet.html
Stir in the rennet mixture thoroughly in an up and downward motion for a minute or two to evenly distribute the cream.  The temp is still at 88˚ F.  Cover and let set for 1 hour.
After an hour the milk will have coagulated nice to a jello consistency.  Simply get a long knife and cut the curd in a checkered board fashion.  Let the cut curds sit for 5 minutes.
Begin heating the milk while stirring constantly.  You do not want the curds to form a matted ball.
Turn the heat off when you reach 100˚F.  Let set another 5 minutes at that temp.
Ladle the curds into a sieve.  I like to use all the whey that drains off to feed the pigs or chickens.  It is really good protein to help make them strong!  Nothing goes to waste on our homestead!
Add 1 Tablespoon per gallon of milk used.  I started with 3 gallons, so I used 3 Tablespoons of sea salt.
Massage the salt into the curds.  You will notice a lot of whey being expelled and that is normal.
Add the curd to a jelly bag.
As you hold it up, you will notice a lot of whey dripping out of the bag which is great!
Next, I hang the bag over the stock pot so the whey can drain.  
Cover the pot to keep the heat in.  Leave dripping for a couple hours.
Remove from the bag.
Cut the cheese into slabs.
This is what it should look like…
To wick out the whey, I bandage each slab of cheese individually with paper toweling.
I layer the bandaged slabs into a flat container so that they are as level in two stacks as possible.
I set a stock pot on top of the slab stacks and then follow it with a heavy object to weigh it down.  I use a mortar and pestle that is made of stone.  It is about 5 pounds.  
I set this in my refrigerator over night.  This helps from the cheese getting to acidic.  In warmer weather, you will grow more bacteria the longer it sits out in the heat.  I learned that the hard way!
This cheese turns out semi-hard, but it so delicious fresh!  I used to press in a really big heavy press, then wax and age.  Well, we just can’t wait for our cheese.  We make about 6 pounds of cheese a week and believe me it gets used up.  It grates well, melts well, and cuts really nice.  The kids eat it fresh!  It squeaks when you chew it and tastes like cheddar cheese curds.  Lovely!  

This is my newest method which is of course, a unique style of cheese making, unique to me!  I have been making cheese for about 10 years now and through the years I have perfected the art of cheese making to what we like.  We find we like a certain semi-hard texture coupled with a mild flavor.  I do it this way because we like it better!  You do what works for you.  

Keeper of the Homestead is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.

Related Posts

Toasted Custard

Sunday morning tradition: the toasted custard!!! I topped mine with cranberries which is my favorite! What is your Sunday morning

Read More »

12 thoughts on “Raw Cheddar Cheese”

  1. Thank you for the post! Do you worry about the cheese not be pasteurized? Thought the milk needed to be heated to about 195F to achieve this or the cheese aged greater than 3 months….?

  2. Hi! I made this cheese and it was great. Thank you so much for the recipe! One question, I followed the link you provided for the jelly bag and ordered it. It is way smaller than your bag so doesn’t fit a real large batch of cheese. Where do I find the huge bag? Thanks

  3. Great tutorial, Erin! Could you show us how to make yogurt next? I have attempted several times, but each time it failed. I would love to know how others make yogurt without electricity. I did not have success with the cooler and hot water method. I’m sure I did something wrong. Thanks so much! Hope to hear from you soon and still looking forward to meeting you in person. God bless!

  4. Thanks for sharing!! We don’t have enough land for a cow (yet), but I recently discovered a source of raw milk at an Amish farm in our area. Unfortunately it’s a 40-45 min drive, so we won’t be going their *every* week. But I am eager to try raw milk for the first time! I’ll def buy enough to try making some cheese when we go!

    1. A Farmer's Wife

      Ashley, many dairy farms will sell you raw milk if you are willing to stop and ask, so if you have a farm closer, well, just ask! I know it might not be as romantic as buying from an Amish dairy, but it is raw and just as good for you!

  5. Thanks for sharing. I’ve never made cheese but I’ve been wanting to learn how. We get our milk from a local dairy. A couple of questions, how many pounds of cheddar did get and how long does it keep? Can you freeze it? Thanks so much for sharing.

  6. Interesting to see how you make cheese! I, too, have developed my own method. We haven’t had enough milk for a long time to make our own, though. We’ve had a drought, and the cow hasn’t calved for a year and a half, although she’s still producing enough for most of our needs.

  7. essay writing reviews

    Such a great post how to make Cheddar cheese. Really looks very interesting. If I had a cow I would do that. But I don’t have it and I have to buy cheese.A pity. Great blog, thanks.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to Top
Malcare WordPress Security